I think there should be a slightly more sophisticated Karma system, a bit like the one on vBulletin (hissss!) Where you get bips, (green good and red bad) and you put phrases in (Thingy has an aurora about) What's best is a possibility to add a comment, which the receiver may see a log on their Profile/User CP What could be better is the amount of reputation you gain/lose depending on the giver's status (high rep, high post count) Sorry if it sounds All too similar, I just like it a little customisable! :D