Reporting some criminals (Skinmod.eu)

[Gary]

^ Just saying that it was adapted, doesn't make it legal.

[NanoSector]

^ Just saying that it was adapted, doesn't make it legal.

Yes, but maybe the site got permission to port/adapt them.

[ARG01]

^ Just saying that it was adapted, doesn't make it legal.

Yes, but maybe the site got permission to port/adapt them.

Many themes have been ported to SMF from other programs. But the fact that it is originally a premium (paid) theme may raise a few questions as to if it was indeed ported legally. Especially since skinmod.eu has suddenly changed their settings to require login to view content since this topic began. That alone may raise a few suspicions about investigating the matter.

[Gary]

It certainly creates some red flags. But like I said earlier, knowing which theme rips off which skin would be needed.

[redone]

You might want to change the title of your form post too, "Reporting some criminals (Skinmod.eu)"

At this point you have no proof that they are engaged in anything remotely criminal. This could be a misunderstanding - to claim "criminal activity" without doing your homework first is a bit much.

Just my 2pence.

[busterone]

I agree as well. They may be, they may not be, but there is no proof offered up as of yet, therefore, it is simply speculation and insinuation at this point.  If it was my site and I was innocent, I would certainly make a huge fuss over the title of this topic.

[Miasma]

Looks like CompleteVB did something. Their themes seem to have been removed from Skinmod site.

But Skinmod's obviously not doing it because they feel guilt, but because CompleteVB stepped in.

All other styles are still there.

Another ripped example (Original theme by VBStyles.com):


As I said earlier not every theme is probably 100% rip-off.
So what? No ripper is an artist. Keeping their themes here just helps them make money or fame off someone.
Once a black sheep, always a black sheep.

@ last 2 guys: read the topic.

[Deaks]

Misama have you reported the themes or given us a list.

[busterone]

Looks like CompleteVB did something.
@ last 2 guys: read the topic.

I have read it. Until there is positive proof, I still say the topic title is wrong.

[Gary]

Given Matt's reply on the CompletevB site, pretty much confirms it.

But like I've said before, I still need a list of specific themes to remove from our theme site.

[ARG01]

Given Matt's reply on the CompletevB site, pretty much confirms it.

But like I've said before, I still need a list of specific themes to remove from our theme site.

Well since it seems that this has been considered confirmed by a staff member, It may be of SMF's best interests to simply remove all of skinmod.eu themes from the site. At least until an actual mutual confirmation can be agreed upon by all staff or proof is shown. 
Until skinmod.eu shows up to state their case there is really no logical reason to take the chance of supporting anyone who may be suspected of offering ripped, copyrighted material.

[Deaks]

i actually agree.

[Account Abandoned]

Yay, means I get to look for a new theme and custom logo....

[青山 素子]

What might be even better for relations is to reach out to the site that supposedly had their items stolen, let them know the team was given reason to suspect that some submissions are in violation of copyright and asking if they could point out any themes from this user that are unauthorized. It shouldn't be hard to pass along a link with only that user's submissions.

[busterone]

Given Matt's reply on the CompletevB site, pretty much confirms it.

But like I've said before, I still need a list of specific themes to remove from our theme site.

OK, at least there is something else to go on, so I retract my earlier statement about this topic title being too harsh.

[ARG01]

Given Matt's reply on the CompletevB site, pretty much confirms it.

But like I've said before, I still need a list of specific themes to remove from our theme site.

OK, at least there is something else to go on, so I retract my earlier statement about this topic title being too harsh.

The more info that comes in, the more people understand the actual issue.  The more one discovers, the better chances of one understanding. No real need to retract as everyone has their opinions and, opinions can change at any given time. That's the beauty of debate and conflict.

[busterone]

True that is. 

[Neekiinh0]

Espero que esten contentos, skinmod removio todas las adaptaciones de vb4 y completevb.

[Gary]

Use English in non-language boards.

Via Google:

I hope you are happy, skinmod removed all vb4 and completevb adaptations.

[ARG01]

Use English in non-language boards.

Via Google:

I hope you are happy, skinmod removed all vb4 and completevb adaptations.

Works for me.