Show Unread Posts lists Sticky Posts Oddly

[Sapphire_H]

I'm running a newly upgraded 1.1.1 forum.  When members use the "Show Unread Posts Since Last Visit" link, the results for topics that are Sticky display very strangely.

I have the following mods currently installed:
   Mod Name        Version     

1.    SMF 1.0.7 / 1.1 RC2 Update    1.0
2.    MessagePreviewOnHover    1.4
3.    SMF Staff Page       1.5.1
4.    Enchanced post template    1.0.2
5.    SMF Links       1.6.3
6.    VisualWarning       1.31
7.    Search Topic       1.01
8.    Custom Profile Field Mod    3.16
9.    View Only Boards       1.0
10.    Ignore Boards       2.0.1

This is happening in both Firefox and IE.  I am attaching a screen shot from each below.

This one has me baffled - I've tried searching here, but none of the results appear to apply to this particular issue. 

Thanks for any guidance you can offer!

[NEMINI]

did you used to have the Sticky First Post (extends sticky topic) mod installed?

[SleePy]

MessagePreviewOnHover I believe is failing from what it looks like. you should ask the mod author about this.

[Sapphire_H]

Hi Nemini - no, I've never used that mod.

SleePy - thanks, I'll do that!

[NEMINI]

ahh yes you are right sleepy ... I had that same issue just forgot which mod it was ... that issue is caused by failure to do the theme edits in your custom theme.