Import Smilies possible bug

[TXSherry]

I say possible because it's late, and I've never worked with this before, but I don't think it's doing what it should be.

Here's what gives, I have SMF 1.01, I have two smiley sets, classic and default, and classic is set as the "default" (iykwim!)   
http://www.pflame.org/forum/ssadmin.jpg
> I make a new directory via ftp  Smileys/silly/ 
> ftp into it some new smilies
>[admin]> [smilies & smiley sets]>[new smiley set] 
>>> name it "silly"
>>> point it to existing directory
>>> Import smilies already in this directory

Then, without changing the default set I go to a new post and it's pretty messed up.
http://www.pflame.org/forum/ssmoz.jpg  Firefox
http://www.pflame.org/forum/ssie.jpg     IE

when I delete smf_smilies and replace with the backup_ table it looks fine again, will double check this go round...

Yep, it's fine.  here's ie after restoring backup of table:
http://www.pflame.org/forum/ssie2.jpg

If this isn't a bug, if it's a skinware problem, my apologies    I haven't taken a lot of time customizing yet, just thought I'd throw in a few extra smilies!  *g*

--Sh

[[Unknown]]

SMF expects all smiley sets to include all smileys.

-[Unknown]

[TXSherry]

Hmm.  I don't follow.   I created a new set, and put in *all* smilies., and that's when it choked. 

Was I not  supposed to click "import smilies" ?   Because that's when the problem started.

Note that I still hadn't told it to actually USE the new set, and the POST screen was popping up references to the images from the other set (yet not the actual images).

[[Unknown]]

The point is, let's say you have two sets.

One has "smiley.gif" and the other has "super.gif".  The respective icons are ":smiley:" and ":super:".

If I'm using set #1, and I type :smiley:, I get .  However, if I'm using set #2, and I type :smiley:... what should I get?  Just :smiley:?  Or what?

If you have a "smiley.gif" in one set, you have to have it in all sets.  When you imported smileys, you put more smileys in your new set than you have in your other sets.

-[Unknown]

[TXSherry]

The point is, let's say you have two sets.

One has "smiley.gif" and the other has "super.gif".  The respective icons are ":smiley:" and ":super:".

If I'm using set #1, and I type :smiley:, I get .  However, if I'm using set #2, and I type :smiley:... what should I get?  Just :smiley:?  Or what?

If you have a "smiley.gif" in one set, you have to have it in all sets.  When you imported smileys, you put more smileys in your new set than you have in your other sets.

-[Unknown]

Cool, got it     Thanks!   I should have come back here after I understood.  The problem was in my use of the word 'set' vs. SMF use of it.   Once I browsed the db it was clear.   And I've been having fun with customizations!